Kimberly Suskind, Ted Wioncek III and AJ Mendini.
The Nerd starts season at Players Circle Theater
You can invite him in. Getting him to leave is another story.
Players Circle Theater kicks off its 2026–27 season with Larry Shue’s The Nerd, a Broadway farce about a debt of gratitude that becomes a test of endurance.
Performances run Oct. 23 through Nov. 15, with discounted previews Oct. 20 – 22, at the theater’s intimate McGregor Boulevard venue.
Artistic director Robert Cacioppo directs the production, returning to Shue’s comedy after previously directing The Foreigner.
“Having directed The Foreigner, I know how beautifully Larry Shue builds a comedy,” said Cacioppo. “He puts people in an impossible situation, lets them try to behave themselves, and then makes it worse. The harder they try to hold everything together, the funnier it gets.”
The production stars Players Circle ensemble members Ted Wioncek III, associate artistic director; Kimberly Suskind, director of education; and AJ Mendini, director of outreach. Joining them are Lucy Sundby, TJ Albertson, and Reid Wylie are making their Players Circle debuts, and Gregg Weiner, appearing under an Actors’ Equity Association Special Appearance Contract.
The Nerd follows a young architect whose life is disrupted by an unexpected visit from the man who once saved his life. Naturally, a little hospitality is in order. Unfortunately, his visitor’s astonishing lack of social graces soon turns gratitude into desperation.
An important dinner with a business client goes spectacularly wrong. Grown adults wind up with paper bags over their heads. A ridiculous party game called “Shoes and Socks” sends whatever dignity remains straight out the window. At the center of it all is a guest whose manners couldn’t be worse and who couldn’t be having a better time.
As Rick settles in, his hosts resort to increasingly outrageous attempts to make him leave. Polite hints don’t stand a chance, and keeping the peace becomes harder by the minute. Getting him through dinner is one thing. Getting him out the door will take considerably more effort.
Wioncek takes on the title role, an unwelcome visitor who remains blissfully unaware of the havoc he creates.
“It’s a role I’ve had a lifetime of practice for,” joked Wioncek. “What I love about this guy is that he thinks the evening is going beautifully. Everyone else is looking for an escape route, and he’s settling in. That’s a wonderful thing to play. I get to spend the night making my fellow actors absolutely miserable, and hopefully they’ll still speak to me afterward.”
The cast and director are bringing that comic friction into the rehearsal room, testing ideas and finding fresh ways to turn an awkward encounter into complete chaos.
“The rehearsal room is filled with big choices and even bigger laughs,” said Wioncek. “We’re stealing a little inspiration from What About Bob?, Dinner for Schmucks, The Man Who Came to Dinner and Planes, Trains and Automobiles. There’s something irresistible about watching someone try desperately to remain polite while one person makes that absolutely impossible.”
“There’s tremendous freedom in working with an ensemble that trusts one another,” said Cacioppo. “You can try something outrageous, fall flat, laugh about it and try again. And I get to play, too! They’ll try something that gives me an idea, I’ll throw something back, and suddenly we’re taking the scene somewhere none of us expected. That trust lets us push each other. The one-upmanship is great fun, and together we find what really makes the scene work.”
Regular performances take place Wednesday through Saturday at 7:30 p.m., with matinees Wednesday, Saturday and Sunday at 3 p.m. Opening week begins with Tuesday through Thursday previews and a Friday opening night.
The Nerd opens the seven-show “Love, Laughter, Legacy” season, which also includes It’s a Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play, Social Security, Marjorie Prime, Bright Star, Eisenhower: This Piece of Ground and Sylvia.
Purchase tickets for “The Nerd” online here or call 239-800-3292.
YOUR DONATION WILL MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Make a Donation.
“A donation to Players Circle Theater is an investment in our community and our vision of putting theater at the heart of public life. Learn more about ways to give and exclusive benefits for our donor family of individual and institutional supporters.”
